The Sutton Penny Loafer

★★★★★
4.7/5 | Based on 2590+ Reviews

The Sutton Penny Loafer

$283.95 $84.95 EARLY AUTUMN SALE!
Free shipping with USPS
30-day money-back guarantee
Pay securely with Credit Card or PayPal
Almost sold out - 2 items left
Ships by
Free Shipping
WHY SUSAN & LAURA?
Every piece is carefully selected for real women — real bodies, real lives, real confidence. Due to high demand during our EARLY Autumn Sale, stock is extremely limited. If you can still click 'Add to Cart', your size is still yours — don't wait.

The classic penny loafer, in a crisp two-tone.

Susan & Laura cuts the Sutton with a glossy finish, a contrasting vamp, and a traditional penny strap.

The Details

  • Classic penny loafer shape
  • High-shine two-tone finish
  • Low stacked heel
  • Available in white and blue

For the woman who loves preppy style done well.

Cuffed jeans, a cable knit, and these.

Every package from us includes a handy Track & Trace code, so you can follow your order’s journey every step of the way! You'll receive your code via email within 24-72 hours after placing your order. Stay in the loop and get excited for your delivery!

If our product doesn't meet your expectations, no worries! You can return it within 30 days of receipt. Just reach out to our friendly customer service at contact@susanlaura.com and let us know why you’re returning it, this helps us process your request smoothly.

Check our return policy for more details! We’re here to help!

Have questions or need assistance? Our dedicated customer service team is available around the clock to help! Whether you’re seeking product advice or need support with your order, we’ve got your back.

Don’t hesitate to reach out, we’re always happy to assist you!

AN AUTUMN LIFE, SHARED

A small thank you from us.

Inspired by the golden warmth of autumn living, our collection is designed to bring comfort, confidence, and effortless style to every day.

Celebrate our EARLY Autumn sale with exclusive savings on some of our most-loved styles.

Enjoy up to 70% OFF selected styles, plus extra savings when you shop more.

With love,

Susan & Laura ♡

Here's what our customers say

★★★★★

LISA BALDWIN

I was a little worried about ordering clothes online at my age but the size guide was spot on. Very happy with the fit.

★★★★

KATHY WHITE

Finally something that fits right
I've ordered from so many places and always had to return something. This time everything was perfect right out of the box. I'll definitely be ordering again.

★★★★★

CONNIE DELANEY

I have worn it three times in one week. That probably says it all.

★★★★

Looks so much better than I expected
I was a little skeptical ordering online but when I put it on I was genuinely surprised. It fits beautifully and I've already gotten compliments wearing it out.

★★★★★

CARMEN DOYLE

Great Service!

Wasn’t sure what to expect, but the whole experience felt thoughtful. From the email updates to the dresses.

★★★★★

WENDY MONROE

I am in my late 60s and do not like anything too tight. This has just the right shape without clinging.

★★★★★

LOIS MCCONNEL

Perfect for warm afternoons here in Florida. Breezy and light but still holds its shape.

★★★★

EVELYN RHODES

Was hesitant at first because I hadn’t heard of the brand, but now I’m glad I gave it a chance. I’ll be back.

COMBINE & SAVE UP TO 25%

View all
Sale
Miren | Black and White Abstract Quilted Jacket
$195.00 $69.95 Save 64%
Sale
Niva | Vintage Floral Print Quilted Jacket
$195.00 $74.95 Save 62%
Sale
Eira | Casual Black Cat Halloween Print Quilted Jacket
$230.00 $69.95 Save 70%
Sale
Camille Painted Garden Quilted Jacket
$240.00 $71.95 Save 70%
Sale
Naya – Quilted Floral Tapestry Jacket
$200.00 $59.95 Save 70%

COMBINE & SAVE UP TO 25%

View all
Sale
Kamberly™ | Boho-Chic Floral Embroidered Utility Ruffled Trim Jacket
$232.95 $69.95 Save 70%
Sale
Bristow™ | Vintage Gradient Textured Print Ruffle Jacket
$199.95 $59.95 Save 70%
Sale
Ruffelle™ | Ruffled Jacket
$199.95 $64.95 Save 68%
Sale
Brielle™ | Floral Embroidered Utility Ruffle Jacket
$138.00 $64.95 Save 53%
Sale
Greta | Ruffled Button-Front Jacket
$127.95 $59.95 Save 53%

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Yes, we offer Free Premium Shipping on all orders. Every order includes tracked delivery, because we want your Susan & Laura pieces to reach you quickly and safely.

Of course. You may return your order within 30 days of receiving it. All items must be unworn and in their original condition. Simply reach out to us at contact@susanlaura.com and we'll take care of you.

Once your order ships, you will receive a tracking number by email. Simply enter it on our Track Your Order page to view real-time updates on your delivery.

You can check out securely using:
Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and Shop Pay.

Yes — as soon as your order is placed, you'll receive an order confirmation email. If you don't see it, please check your spam folder or reach out to us at contact@susanlaura.com. We're always here to help.

Every product page includes a detailed size guide. Most items fit true to size. If you're between sizes, we recommend sizing up for a more comfortable fit. Still unsure? Email us at contact@susanlaura.com and we'll help.